| 2012 |
Bill Stoudt, '71, Pendleton Heights |
| 2011 |
Brian Dudley, '80, Wapahani |
| 2010 |
Mike Hepler, '90, Warsaw Community |
| 2009 |
Bob Bowman, '71, Seymour |
| 2008 |
Eric Lentz, '90, Carmel |
| 2007 |
Greg Dikos, '80, Penn |
| 2006 |
Robert Shinkan, '75, Munster |
| 2005 |
Brian Dudley, '80, Wapahani |
| 2004 |
Brian Dudley, '80, Wapahani |
| 2003 |
Bill Stoudt, '71, Pendleton Heights |
| 2002 |
Jim Turner, '82, Logansport |
| 2001 |
Don Sherman, '63, Huntington North |
| 2000 |
Bob Strecher, '68, Anderson Highland |
| 1999 |
Bill Nixon, '62, Plymouth |
| 1998 |
Bill Stoudt, '71, Pendleton Heights |
| 1994 |
Greg Dikos, '80, Penn |
| 1984 |
Mel Wysong, '75, Marion |