| 2013 | Craig Teagle '86, Jay County |
| 2012 | Chris Johnson '88, Homestead |
| 2011 | Jim East '62, Merrillville |
2010 | Jeremy Duncan '00, Monroe Central |
2009 | David Bradshaw '84, Jac-Cen-Del |
2008 | Jim Shannon '82, New Albany |
2007 | Jim Gish '95, Northwestern |
2006 | Craig Teagle '86, Jay County |
2005 | Matt Fine '98, Muncie Central |
2004 | Chris Benedict '89, Columbia City |
2003 | Basil Mawbey '64, Cass |
2002 | Wayne Barker '89, Bluffton |
2001 | Al Gooden '81, Harding |
2000 | Moe Smedley '66, Marion |
1999 | Keith Hipskind '79, Greensburg |
1998 | Joe Bradburn '89, Yorktown |
1997 | Paul Keller '78, Delta |
1996 | Christopher Johnson '88, Fort Wayne Bishop Dwenger - James Hammel, '67, Lake Central |
1995 | James East '62, Merrillville |
1994 | Michael Drews '81, Muncie Central |
1993 | Robert Heady '64, Carmel |
1992 | George Griffith '64, Richmond |
1991 | Jim Howell '80, Mount Vernon |
1990 | James Hahn '79, Concord |
1989 | John Keefer '65, Lawrence North |
1988 | James Hahn '79, Concord |
1987 | Steven Bennett '70, Lafayette Central - Robert Kovatch '71, Indiana School for the Deaf |
1986 | Steven Bennett '70, Lafayette Central |
1985 | George Griffith '64, Richmond |
1984 | James Hammel '67, Lake Central |
1983 | Basil Mawbey '64, Connersville |
1982 | James Irwin '65, Southern Wells |
1981 | Robert Heady '64, Shenandoah |
1980 | Robert Fuller '62, Anderson Highland |
1979 | Paul Curtis '56, Crawfordsville |
1978 | Stanley Neal '65, Washington |
1977 | George Griffith '64, South Bend LaSalle |
1976 | Robert Fuller '62, Highland |
1975 | Irvin Pratt '54, Northridge |
1974 | Phillip Snodgress '63, Union County |
1973 | Kirby Overman '62, New Albany |
1972 | Myron Dickerson '56, Connersville |
1971 | Kirby Overman '62, Batesville |
1970 | Doug Adams '49, Michigan City |
1969 | Harry Allison '49, Crown Point |
1968 | John Cross '55, Bluffton |
1967 | Joseph Stanley '59, Liberty |
1966 | Doug Adams '49, Michigan City |
1965 | Jerry Oliver '53, Indianapolis Washington |
1964 | Robert Straight '50, Huntington |
1963 | Robert Straight '50, Huntington |
1962 | Von Jameson '36, Middletown |
1961 | Robert Straight '50, Huntington |
1960 | Virgil Kirkpatrick '52, Bluffton |
1959 | Doug Adams '49, Michigan City |
1958 | Virgil Kirkpatrick '52, Bluffton |