| 2012 |
Jon Hoover, '89, Westfield |
| 2011 |
Jim Finchum, '92, DeKalb |
| 2010 |
Jim Hughes, '66, Franklin County |
| 2009 |
Jim Finchum, '92, DeKalb |
| 2008 |
Brad Baughman, '79, Brown County |
| 2007 |
Keith Turner, '95, Carmel |
| 2006 |
Bill Mattingly, '76, Indianapolis Cathedral |
| 2005 |
Ron Murphy, '87, Richmond |
| 2004 |
Mike Moore, '68, Noblesville |
| 2003 |
Ron Murphy, '87, Richmond |
| 2002 |
Ron Murphy, '87, Richmond |
| 2001 |
Ron Murphy, '87, Richmond |
| 2000 |
Jim Slain, '84, Garrett |
| 1999 |
Ted Oliger, '65, Cambridge City Lincoln |
| 1998 |
Jerry Newland, '70, New Castle Chrysler |
| 1990 |
Donald Huffer, '57, Carmel |
| 1989 |
Donald Huffer, '57, Carmel |
| 1986 |
John Bingaman, '62, Kokomo |
| 1985 |
John Bingaman, '62, Kokomo |
| 1983 |
George Hultgren, '49, Michigan City |
| 1982 |
Donald Huffer, '57, Carmel |
| 1975 |
Jack Jorden, '67, Yorktown |
| 1974 |
Phillip Sullivan, '63, Union City |
| 1973 |
Donald Huffer, '57, Carmel |
| 1970 |
Donald Huffer, '57, Carmel |