| 2012 | Mike Bostic '96, Carmel |
| 2011 | Mike Bostic '96, Carmel |
| 2010 | Mike Bostic '96, Carmel |
| 2009 | Jim Clark '68, Homestead |
| 2008 | Dan Layton '05, Zionsville |
| 2007 | Randy Ecker '79, Centerville |
| 2006 | Jim Clark '68, Homestead |
| 2005 | Barry Weaver '75, Jay County |
| 2004 | Mike Bostic '96, Carmel |
| 2003 | Mike Bostic '96, Carmel |
| 2002 | Tim Cleland '87, Delta |
| 2001 | Kyle Stoffel '91, Carroll |
| 2000 | Tim Cleland '87, Delta |
| 1999 | Jim Clark '68, Homestead |
| 1998 | Tim Cleland '87, Delta |
| 1997 | Tim Cleland '87, Delta |
| 1974 | Joseph Saine '50, Peru |