| 2011 |
Bob Gaddis, '78, Columbus East |
| 2010 |
John Fallis, '66, Hagerstown |
| 2009 |
Grant Zgunda, '90, Delta |
| 2008 |
Larry "Bud" Wright, '63, Sheridan |
| 2007 |
Larry "Bud" Wright, '63, Sheridan |
| 2006 |
Tim Dawson, '81, Concord |
| 2005 |
Larry "Bud" Wright, '63, Sheridan |
| 2004 |
Bob Gaddis, '78, Columbus East |
| 2003 |
John Hochstetler, '92, Muncie Central |
| 2002 |
John Hochstetler, '92, Muncie Central |
| 2001 |
Grant Zgunda, '90, Delta |
| 2000 |
Grant Zgunda, '90, Delta |
| 1999 |
Bob Gaddis, '78, Evansville Reitz |
| 1998 |
Larry "Bud" Wright, '63, Sheridan |
| 1997 |
Donald Willard, '64, Knightstown |
| 1996 |
John Hendryx, '86, Carroll |
| 1995 |
John Hendryx, '86, Carroll |
| 1994 |
Martin Huber, '77, Bremen |
| 1993 |
Ernie Beck, '59, West Lafayette |
| 1992 |
Daniel Robinson, '73, Northwestern |
| 1991 |
John Fallis, '66, Greencastle |
| 1990 |
David Wilhelm, '69, Southwood |
| 1989 |
Gerald Vlasic, '62, Hammond Bishop Noll |
| 1988 |
Mark Surface, '68, Marion |
| 1987 |
Larry Wright, '63, Sheridan |
| 1986 |
Michael Hawley, '68, Fort Wayne Snider |
| 1985 |
Myrson Dickerson, '61, Wawasee |
| 1984 |
George Conn, '72, Concord |
| 1983 |
Joseph Jackson, '55, Anderson Highland |
| 1982 |
Frank O'Shea, '63, McCutcheon |
| 1981 |
Leland Etzler, '62, Woodlan |
| 1980 |
Larry Wright, '63, Sheridan |
| 1979 |
Myron Dickerson, '61, Fort Wayne Northside |
| 1978 |
Victor Overman, '46, Brownsburg |
| 1977 |
William Nixon, '62, Plymouth |
| 1976 |
William Nixon, '62, Plymouth |
| 1975 |
David Land, '69. Wes-Del |
| 1974 |
William Doba, '62, Mishawaka |
| 1973 |
Robert Van Camp, '50, South Bend Washington |
| 1972 |
William Doba, '62, Mishawaka |
| 1971 |
William Doba, '62, Mishawaka |
| 1970 |
Ted Huber, '67, Hamilton Heights |
| 1969 |
Steve Lookabaugh, '64, Delta |
| 1968 |
James Hollibaugh, '51, Logansport |
| 1967 |
Hubert Etchison, '39, Richmond |
| 1966 |
Donald Wiggs, '59, Winchester |
| 1965 |
Jack Lowe, '57, North Liberty |
| 1964 |
Robert Baker, '51, Madison Heights |
| 1963 |
Hubert Etchison, '39, Richmond |
| 1962 |
Hubert Etchison, '39, Richmond |
| 1961 |
Hubert Etchison, '39, Richmond |
| 1960 |
William Lynch, '49, New Castle |
| 1961 |
Hubert Etchison, '39, Richmond |
| 1959 |
Victor Overman, '46, Michigan City |
| 1958 |
Charles Myers, '50, Huntington |
| 1957 |
William McClain, '50, Noblesville |