| 2013 | Chris Huppenthal, '89, Hamilton Southeastern |
| 2012 | Eric Thornton, '92, Norwell |
| 2011 | Chris Oliger, '91, Hagerstown |
| 2010 | Alana Harrington, '96, Bloomington North |
| 2009 | Chris Huppenthal, '89, Hamilton Southeastern |
| 2008 | Chris Huppenthal, '89, Hamilton Southeastern |
| 2007 | Gene Johnson, '76, Jimtown |
| 2006 | Chris Huppenthal, '89, Hamilton Southeastern |
| 2005 | Todd Salkoski, '80, Shenandoah |
| 2004 | Todd Salkoski, '80, Shenandoah |
| 2003 | Charlie Hall, '80, Kokomo |
| 2002 | Todd Salkoski, '80, Shenandoah |
| 2001 | Charlie Hall, '80, Kokomo |
| 2000 | Mark Fette, '87, Rising Sun |
| 1999 | Charlie Hall, '80, Kokomo |
| 1998 | Rick Myers, '69, Jeffersonville |
| 1996 | James Hammel, '67, Lafayette Jefferson |
| 1990 | Frederick Fields, '73, Huntington |
| 1987 | Ray Lyttle, '76, Noblesville |
| 1986 | David Riley, '57, Fort Wayne Northrop |
| 1982 | Cheri Gilbert, '76, Heritage |
| 1978 | Janice Soyez, '66, Warsaw |
| 1976 | Janice Soyez, '66, Warsaw |