| 2011 |
Ken Kelly, '79, Carmel |
| 2010 |
Ken Kelly, '79, Carmel |
| 2009 |
Ken Kelly, '79, Carmel |
| 2008 |
Jack Cooper, '77, Columbus North |
| 2007 |
Ken Kelly, '79, Carmel |
| 2006 |
Bill Mattingly, '76, Indianapolis Cathedral |
| 2005 |
Jim Garrett, '71, Penn |
| 2004 |
Jim Garrett, '71, Penn |
| 2003 |
Jim Garrett, '71, Penn |
| 2002 |
Jim Garrett, '71, Penn |
| 2001 |
Jim Garrett, '71, Penn |
| 2000 |
John Engle, '65, Jay County |
| 1999 |
Scott Herring, '92, Yorktown |
| 1998 |
Scott Herring, '92, Yorktown |
| 1997 |
James Garrett, '71, Penn |
| 1984 |
Jean Hilkert, '54, Lafayette Jefferson |
| 1983 |
Jean Hilkert, '54, Lafayette Jefferson |
| 1979 |
Jean Hilkert, '54, Lafayette Jefferson |