| 2012 |
Brian McEvoy, '03, Jay County |
| 2011 |
Brian McEvoy, '03, Jay County |
| 2010 |
Steve Cotherman, '72, East Central |
| 2009 |
Mike Miller, '79, Carroll (Flora) |
| 2008 |
Joe Brinker '98, Carroll (Fort Wayne) |
| 2007 |
Steve Kearney '70, Chesterton |
| 2006 |
Tom Knudson '81, Fort Wayne Northrop |
| 2005 |
Steve Kearney '70, Chesterton |
| 2004 |
Brad Peterson '96, Concordia Lutheran |
| 2003 |
Steve Kearney '70, Chesterton |
| 2002 |
Lisa Wesley '82, Concordia Lutheran |
| 2001 |
Bryant Branigan '94, North Central-Indianapolis |
| 2000 |
Mike Haviland '71, Muncie Central |
| 1999 |
Mike Haviland '71, Muncie Central |
| 1998 |
Lisa Wesley '82, Concordia Lutheran |