| 2012 | Todd Vanderweele, '95, Argos |
| 2011 | Todd Vanderweele, '95, Argos |
| 2010 | Amanda Isakson, '06, Portage |
| 2009 | Kyle Kendall, '99, Jasper |
| 2008 | Amanda Isakson, ’06, Portage |
| 2007 | James Sensibaugh, '96, Chesterton |
| 2006 | Scott Coil, '00, Lowell |
| 2005 | James Sensibaugh, '96, Chesterton |
| 2004 | Michael Whisler, '79, Valparaiso |
| 2003 | Michael Whisler, '79, Valparaiso |
| 2002 | Sue Rager, '72, Jay County |
| 2001 | Mark Nirrengarten, '92, Avon |
| 2000 | Scott Evans, '90, Westfield |
| 1999 | Chris Schnepp, '88, Hamilton Southeastern |
| 1998 | Scott Evans, '90, Westfield |
| 1997 | Mitzi Owens, '81, Avon |