| 2012 |
Paris Seibold '78, Huntington North |
| 2011 |
Jason Stewart '99, Greenfield Central |
| 2010 |
Abby Willis '03, Harrison (West Lafayette) |
| 2009 |
Jason Stewart '99, Greenfield Central |
| 2008 |
Scott Hall '99, Pendleton Heights |
| 2007 |
Scott Hall '99, Pendleton Heights |
| 2006 |
Paris Seibold '78, Huntington North |
| 2005 |
Keith Hauber '78, Lake Central |
| 2004 |
Joe Tilford '69, Indianapolis Lutheran |
| 2003 |
Jennifer Mascari '99, Culver Academies |
| 2002 |
Keith Hauber '78, Lake Central |
| 2001 |
Keith Hauber '78, Lake Central |
| 2000 |
Joe Tilford '69, Indianapolis Lutheran |
| 1999 |
Todd Croy '86, Whiteland Community |
| 1998 |
Dave Cook '85, Hamilton Southeastern |
| 1990 |
Brett Stoker '83, Tipton |
| 1985 |
David Stroud '72, Warren Central |