| 2011 |
Biff Wilson '98, Wes-Del |
| 2010 |
Lisa Pawlik '84, Penn |
| 2009 |
Stephanie Bloom '05, Yorktown |
| 2008 |
Steven Shondell '77, Muncie Burris |
| 2007 |
Craig Krull '00, Bellmont |
| 2006 |
Kathy Nalley-Schembra '72, Roncalli |
| 2005 |
Mary Goth '77, Cowan |
| 2004 |
Steven Shondell '77, Muncie Burris |
| 2003 |
Wes Lyon '77, Muncie Central |
| 2002 |
David Shondell '81, Muncie Central |
| 2001 |
John Shondell '94, New Castle Chrysler |
| 2000 |
Lisa Pawlik '84, Penn |
| 1999 |
Curtis Johnston '90, Michigan City Marquette |
| 1998 |
Kathy Schembra '72, Roncalli |
| 1997 |
David Shondell '81, Muncie Central |
| 1994 |
Steven Shondell '77, Muncie Burris |
| 1993 |
Steven Shondell '77, Muncie Burris |
| 1992 |
Steven Shondell '77, Muncie Burris |
| 1991 |
Thomas Beerman '63, Fort Wayne Snider |
| 1990 |
Steven Shondell '77, Muncie Burris |
| 1989 |
Steven Shondell '77, Muncie Burris |
| 1988 |
Thomas Beerman '63, Fort Wayne Snider |
| 1986 |
Steven Shondell '77, Muncie Burris |
| 1985 |
Steven Shondell '77, Muncie Burris |
| 1982 |
Steven Shondell '77, Muncie Burris |
| 1981 |
Kathy Schembra '72, Roncalli |
| 1979 |
Priscilla Dillow '66, Ben Davis |
| 1977 |
Denise Van DeWalle '76, Muncie Northside |