| 2013 | Mike Bottomley '92, Connersville |
| 2012 | Terry O'Neill '99, Westfield |
| 2011 | Greg Gastineau '91, Hamilton Southeastern |
| 2010 | Trent McCormick '91, Yorktown |
| 2009 | Trent McCormick '91, Yorktown |
| 2008 | Trent McCormick '91, Yorktown |
| 2007 | Scott Schwarz '88, East Central |
| 2006 | Scott Schwarz '88, East Central |
| 2005 | Rex Leavitt '71, Elwood Community |
| 2004 | Craig Standish '94, Eastern (Greentown) |
| 2003 | Lance Wildoner '94, Harrison |
| 2002 | Ron Anderson '73, Winchester |
| 2001 | Trent McCormick '91, Yorktown |
| 2000 | Trent McCormick '91, Yorktown |
| 1999 | Andy Hobbs '91, Peru |
| 1998 | Trent McCormick '91, Yorktown |
| 1990 | John Smith '73, Muncie Southside |
| 1988 | Dennis Hays '79, Bellmont |
| 1987 | Dennis Hays '79, Bellmont |
| 1985 | Donald Patton, '69, Delta |
| 1984 | Donald Patton, '69, Delta |
| 1983 | Donald Patton, '69, Delta |
| 1982 | Donald Patton, '69, Delta |
| 1981 | Donald Patton, '69, Delta |
| 1980 | Donald Patton, '69, Delta |
| 1975 | James Cartwright '61, Muncie Southside |
| 1974 | Fred Ginther '63, Muncie Northside |